What it is
Trades on an exchange like a stock. Lends to and invests in US companies too small for the bond market, typically earning $10-250M a year before interest and taxes.
Pays at least 90% of taxable income as dividends to avoid corporate tax. Little is kept back, so earnings and dividend move together.
Most loans are senior secured and float over a base rate, so income rises with rates and falls when rates are cut.
By law, debt can't exceed 2x equity. Most run around 1.0-1.3x.
The result is a high payout. The BDCs we score pay 6%-35% a year on their book value (NAV). Market yield depends on the share price.
How the dividend gets paid
Every quarter follows the same path. Watching where it breaks is what our score does.
The extra builds spillover or funds a supplemental. NAV holds or grows.
The gap comes from spillover, then from NAV. Do that for a few quarters and the dividend gets cut. 19 of the 45 BDCs we score are below 100% coverage right now.
Who BDCs tend to fit, and who they don't
General characteristics, not a recommendation. Your own situation decides.
Tend to fit
- Income-first investors who want cash now more than growth later.
- Retirees covering expenses who value a quarterly or monthly check.
- IRA and Roth holders. BDC dividends are mostly taxed as ordinary income, so a tax-advantaged account keeps more of the yield. Try the real-yield calculator.
- Investors who check the dividend's safety before buying the yield.
Tend not to fit
- Growth investors. Paying out 90% leaves little to compound inside the company. Share prices tend to move sideways over long periods.
- Anyone who can't sit through big drops. Many BDCs lost roughly half their price in weeks in March 2020, and many cut dividends in 2008-09.
- High-bracket taxable accounts. Ordinary-income tax plus state tax can take a third or more of the yield.
- Money needed soon. A dividend that looks steady can still be cut in one quarter.
The 5 risks that cut BDC dividends
Borrowers default in recessions. Non-accruals rise, NII falls, NAV drops.
Floating-rate income falls when base rates fall, while the dividend stays fixed.
Paying more than it earns shrinks the asset base that produces next year's income.
External managers take base and incentive fees before you're paid. HTGC and MAIN are internally managed.
Raising capital at a discount dilutes existing holders and lowers NAV per share.
Glossary
- BDC
- A business development company is a closed-end investment company, created by Congress in 1980, that lends to and invests in mid-size private US companies. It trades on an exchange like a stock and must pay out at least 90% of its taxable income to avoid corporate tax.
- NII
- Net investment income is what a BDC earns from its loans (interest, fees, dividends) after operating expenses, management fees and interest on its own debt. It excludes gains and losses on investments. It is the BDC equivalent of earnings.
- Coverage if rates fall 1%
- Most BDC loans pay a floating rate, so lower base rates mean lower interest income. Each 10-Q includes a table estimating the annual change in net investment income for rate moves. We take the 100 basis point decrease, convert it to a quarterly per-share amount, and add it to core NII. Many companies show the figure before incentive fees, which would soften the drop. Rate floors and fixed-rate borrowings can make the effect small or even positive.
- Core NII
- Reported NII can be inflated for a quarter by items that won’t repeat: a one-time dividend from a portfolio company, accelerated fees when loans are repaid early, or a temporary fee waiver. Core NII removes disclosed one-time items so coverage reflects what the BDC can earn again next quarter.
- Coverage
- Dividend coverage is core NII per share divided by the regular dividend per share. At 120%, the BDC earns $1.20 for every $1.00 it pays. Below 100%, the gap comes from spillover, from selling assets or from new capital, none of which last.
- Non-accrual
- A loan goes on non-accrual when the BDC no longer expects to collect its interest. That income stops counting toward NII. Rising non-accruals are often the first sign of a future NII shortfall. We use the percentage at fair value; some BDCs only report it at cost.
- Spillover
- Spillover (undistributed taxable income) is income a BDC has earned but not yet distributed. It can cover a short-term NII shortfall without cutting the dividend. A large spillover per share is a real safety buffer.
- PIK
- Payment-in-kind interest is added to what the borrower owes instead of being paid in cash. It counts toward NII, but the BDC receives no cash until the loan is repaid. A rising share of PIK income can mean borrowers are struggling to pay.
- Supplemental dividend
- Many BDCs pay a variable supplemental dividend when earnings run above the regular payout. It can disappear without counting as a cut, so we score coverage of the regular dividend only.
- Debt / equity
- Since 2018, BDCs can operate at 150% asset coverage, which allows debt up to 2x equity. Most run between 0.9x and 1.3x. Higher leverage boosts income but leaves less room to absorb losses.
- Externally managed
- Most BDCs are run by an outside asset manager that charges a base fee on assets and an incentive fee on income. Internally managed BDCs, such as Main Street and Hercules, pay their own staff and usually run at lower cost. Fee structure affects how much income reaches shareholders.
Now check the dividends themselves
Every listed BDC, scored 0-100 on the factors above.